Alexandria Digital Research Library

Toxic "Outliers" and "Mainstreamers": A Facility-Based Analysis of the Predictors of Pollution-Related Health Risk Intensity

Author:
Collins, Mary Bowen
Degree Grantor:
University of California, Santa Barbara. Environmental Science & Management
Degree Supervisor:
Sarah Anderson
Place of Publication:
[Santa Barbara, Calif.]
Publisher:
University of California, Santa Barbara
Creation Date:
2012
Issued Date:
2012
Topics:
Health Sciences, Public Health, Sociology, Environmental Justice, Environmental Sciences, and Sociology, Public and Social Welfare
Keywords:
Environmental Justice
Environmental Policy
Disproportionality
Industrial Pollution
Genres:
Online resources and Dissertations, Academic
Dissertation:
Ph.D.--University of California, Santa Barbara, 2012
Description:

Several key studies have revealed the existence of a small number of heavily polluting facilities that are responsible for generating the majority of emissions-based relative human health risk. Early work has also suggested that such outlier facilities tend to be poor performers economically as well as environmentally, that they place disadvantaged communities at particular risk, and that regulatory responses are not aligned with levels of risk production. To date, little scholarly attention has been devoted to these extreme variations in facility-based risk and to their significance from environmental equity and policy points of view. This research undertakes a number of separate but interrelated studies that focus on the explication of the "disproportionality perspective," or the idea that these heavy polluters produce the majority of environmental harm without compensating societal benefit.

In the first study, I determine the generalizability of disproportionate patterns in industrial pollution risk. Second, I show how this analytic framework can be used by regulators to promote environmental justice. Finally, I move beyond the traditional community-based environmental justice frame to focus on industrial risk intensity and its relationship to community factors. I contrast the riskiest polluters ("toxic outliers") to the lower risk polluters ("mainstreamers") in regard to environmental justice performance. I find that nonwhite and low income populations bear the overwhelming majority of risk from outliers and that outliers have significantly worse environmental justice performance than mainstreamers. I also explore the extent to which such injustices could be relieved if environmental policy compelled outliers to reduce their toxic burdens to the average for their sector.

In entirety, the findings from this work show that disproportionate patterns in pollution production are highly reproducible and influenced by power-based societal dynamics. Findings also suggest that more emphasis should be placed on studying the distribution of environmental privileges as well as environmental problems and on understanding the inherent interconnections between these two sides of environmental inequality.

Physical Description:
1 online resource (156 pages)
Format:
Text
Collection(s):
UCSB electronic theses and dissertations
ARK:
ark:/48907/f3w66hqt
ISBN:
9781267767301
Catalog System Number:
990039147240203776
Rights:
Inc.icon only.dark In Copyright
Copyright Holder:
Mary Collins
Access: This item is restricted to on-campus access only. Please check our FAQs or contact UCSB Library staff if you need additional assistance.